Method Dish Soap: Super Shine or Gel for Your Sink
Every figure on this page is quoted from the Amazon listing for that model. Scores are the average rating Amazon buyers left. Nothing here was handled or measured by us.
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
If you want Method dishwashing liquid, the choice is between the newer Super Shine formula and the classic Gel dish soap, then between a bottle for the sink and a refill or multipack for the cupboard. Super Shine is Method’s enzyme-based formula that the brand says tackles grease, starches and proteins while staying gentle on skin. The Gel line is the Lemon Mint soap that Method describes as tough on grease and made with plant-based cleaning ingredients.
This guide covers three Method listings: a 48 fl oz Super Shine refill in Coastal Citron, a six-pack of 18 fl oz Gel dish soap in Lemon Mint, and a single 16 fl oz Super Shine bottle in Coastal Citron. They differ mostly in formula and size. We compared the listings and what they state, so you can choose the one that suits your sink after a long night of pizza, wings and popcorn.
JOB SHEET
Which Method Dish Soap Should You Buy
- Topping up a Super Shine bottle with the least reordering: method Super Shine Liquid Dish Soap Refill (48 fl oz)
- Stocking up on a proven grease-fighting gel: Method Gel Dish Soap Liquid, Lemon Mint (6-pack)
- Trying Super Shine for the first time, or keeping a bottle by the sink: method Super Shine Liquid Dish Soap (16 fl oz)
No. 01
of 3
Method
method Super Shine Liquid Dish Soap Refill, Coastal Citron, 48 fl oz
4.0
out of 5
Amazon buyer average
Affiliate link. Price and stock live at Amazon and change there, not on this page.
Best for
Trying Super Shine at the sink
Pros
- Enzyme formula for grease and starch
- Described as gentle on skin
- Countertop-ready 16 fl oz bottle
Cons
- Smallest size here
- Runs out fastest in heavy use
Best for
Refilling a Super Shine bottle in bulk
Pros
- Large 48 fl oz refill
- Coastal Citron scent
- Cuts down on bottle buying
Cons
- Listing gives few details
- Needs a bottle to decant into
The method Super Shine Liquid Dish Soap refill is a 48 fl oz container of Super Shine in the Coastal Citron scent. That is three times the volume of the standard 16 fl oz Super Shine bottle in this guide, so it is the size to pick if you already have a bottle at the sink and want to top it up rather than buy new bottles each time.
This listing gives only its title, so we can confirm the formula name, the scent, the refill format and the size, but not the ingredients, packaging material or any performance claims specific to this pack. Because it carries the Super Shine name and the same Coastal Citron scent as the 16 fl oz bottle, it is reasonable to see it as the bulk companion to that bottle, but the listing itself does not spell out the formula details.
It suits households that already like Super Shine and go through dish soap quickly, such as shared apartments or a home that hosts regular game nights. If you have never used Super Shine, start with the 16 fl oz bottle to see whether you like the scent and feel before committing to the larger refill. For more on refilling, see our guide to Method dish soap refills.
- 48 fl oz refill size
- Super Shine formula
- Coastal Citron scent
No. 02
of 3
Method
Method Gel Dish Soap Liquid, Lemon Mint, 18 fl oz (Pack of 6)
4.2
out of 5
Amazon buyer average
Affiliate link. Price and stock live at Amazon and change there, not on this page.
Best for
Households wanting a stocked six-pack
Pros
- Six 18 fl oz bottles
- Plant-based cleaning ingredients
- Lemon Mint, tough on grease
Cons
- Listed weight looks inconsistent
- Six bottles need storage space
The Method Gel Dish Soap Liquid comes as a six-pack of 18 fl oz bottles in Lemon Mint. The title calls it tough on grease, and the description says it is made with plant-based cleaning ingredients and fresh, kitchen-inspired scents. Method also leans on design here, describing a sleek bottle shape meant to look good on a counter.
The six-pack adds up to 108 fl oz, the most total soap of the three listings. That makes it the easy choice if you want a long-lasting supply and do not want to think about dish soap for a while. One detail to note: the listing gives a weight of 1.13 pounds for the package, which seems low for six full 18 fl oz bottles, so treat that specification with caution.
It suits readers who want a plant-based dish soap with a clean citrus and herb scent, and who like having spare bottles for the bathroom sink, a garage sink or a second kitchen. Compared with Super Shine, the Gel listing does not mention enzymes, so if stuck-on starch from pasta or baked cheese is your main problem, the Super Shine description is the more targeted one. Readers comparing plant-based options across brands can see our look at another plant-based dishwashing liquid.
- Six 18 fl oz bottles
- Plant-based cleaning ingredients
- Lemon Mint scent, described as tough on grease
No. 03
of 3
Method
method Super Shine Liquid Dish Soap, Coastal Citron, 16 fl oz
4.3
out of 5
Amazon buyer average
Affiliate link. Price and stock live at Amazon and change there, not on this page.
The method Super Shine Liquid Dish Soap in the 16 fl oz bottle is the most detailed Super Shine listing. Method says powerful enzymes make dishes cleaner, and that the formula is tough on grease, starches and proteins while staying gentle on skin, to the point that the brand suggests you can skip gloves. Coastal Citron blends lemon with floral notes.
Enzymes are a well-established approach in cleaning products: different enzymes help break down specific types of food soil, such as starch or protein, which is why enzyme formulas are often pitched for dried-on residue. That makes Super Shine a logical match for snack plates, cheese-crusted pans and bowls that sat in the sink overnight. The listing names SC Johnson as manufacturer.
It suits anyone trying Super Shine for the first time, or who wants a single bottle for the counter. The 16 fl oz size will run out fastest under heavy use, so pair it with the 48 fl oz refill once you know you like it. The listing does not state whether the bottle is designed to be refilled, but keeping it and topping it up from the larger container is a simple way to cut down on packaging.
- Enzyme-based Super Shine formula
- Targets grease, starches and proteins
- Described as gentle on skin
- Coastal Citron scent
What Sets These Models Apart
| Listing | Formula | Size | Scent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Super Shine Refill | Super Shine | 48 fl oz | Coastal Citron |
| Gel Dish Soap 6-pack | Gel, plant-based | 6 x 18 fl oz | Lemon Mint |
| Super Shine Bottle | Super Shine with enzymes | 16 fl oz | Coastal Citron |
Figures in this table are copied from the Amazon listings for these models.
NOTES
Buying Tips for Method Dish Soap
Start with the mess you usually face. Greasy pizza boxes and wing plates respond well to any good degreasing soap, while dried-on pasta, oatmeal or egg benefit from an enzyme formula like Super Shine. If most of your dishes go in soon after eating, either formula will handle them.
Then think about size and storage. A refill makes sense if you already have a bottle you like and space under the sink. A six-pack spreads soap across several sinks and saves reorders. A single bottle is the low-commitment way to try a scent. Filling a sink with warm water and a small amount of soap, rather than squirting soap straight onto a sponge for each dish, generally makes any bottle last longer.
Scent also matters more than many people expect when the soap sits by the sink every day. Coastal Citron leans citrus and floral, while Lemon Mint mixes citrus with herbal freshness. If you are comparing Method with more traditional degreasers, our guide to a classic blue dishwashing liquid offers a useful contrast.
A few general habits help any dish soap work better. Scrape food into the trash before washing so the soap is not wasted on loose crumbs. Let heavily greased pans soak in hot, soapy water for a few minutes before scrubbing. Rinse glasses and mugs first, then plates, then pans, so the water stays cleaner for longer. These steps matter most after a long session when plates and bowls have been sitting for hours.
FAQ
What is the difference between Method Super Shine and Method Gel dish soap?
Super Shine is described as an enzyme formula for grease, starches and proteins that is gentle on skin. The Gel soap is described as plant-based and tough on grease. The Gel listing does not mention enzymes.
Is the Super Shine refill the same formula as the bottle?
Both carry the Super Shine name and Coastal Citron scent. The refill listing gives only its title, so it does not confirm ingredient details.
Is Method dish soap plant-based?
The Gel listing states it is made with plant-based cleaning ingredients. The Super Shine listings do not use that wording.
Which Method dish soap lasts longest?
By total volume, the Gel six-pack at 108 fl oz, followed by the 48 fl oz Super Shine refill.
Can I skip gloves with Super Shine?
Method describes Super Shine as gentle on skin and suggests you can ditch the gloves. If you have sensitive skin, use your own judgment.
Can Method dish soap go in a dishwasher?
None of these listings says so. They are hand dishwashing liquids, and hand dish soap generally should not go in an automatic dishwasher because it can create excess suds.
