Maytag Freezer Door Handles: Replacement Parts Compared
Every spec and price on this page is quoted from the Amazon listing for that model. Scores are out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback. Nothing here was handled or measured by us.
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
If your Maytag freezer door handle has cracked, snapped at a screw post or worked loose, the fix is usually a single plastic part that swaps in with a screwdriver. For many Maytag top-freezer and bottom-freezer refrigerators, the part to look for is 67005140, also sold as WP67005140. It is shared across Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana and Maytag models, which is why most replacement listings mention several brands at once.
Be clear on one thing before you shop: none of the four products in this Maytag handle comparison are made by Maytag. They are third-party replacement parts designed to fit Maytag appliances, sold under the HSJAWA, HUFEWU and TEKONPRO names. Three of them are 67005140 freezer handles that differ mainly in how they present compatibility and what they include. The fourth is a Maytag microwave handle that shows up in the same searches, and we cover it so you do not buy it by mistake.
JOB SHEET
Which Maytag Handle Should You Buy
- Want to confirm fit against the longest list of Maytag model numbers: the WP67005140 67005140 Refrigerator Freezer Door Handle.
go to no. 01 - Want screws in the box and a clear ABS plastic spec: the 67005140 Refrigerator Freezer Door Handle Fit.
go to no. 02 - Want to match by old part numbers such as 8170990 or 12610801W: the WP67005140 Refrigerator Freezer Door Handle.
go to no. 03 - Need to fix a Maytag over-the-range microwave handle, not a freezer: the WPW10187840 Microwave Door Handle Fits.
go to no. 04
No. 01
of 4
Hsjawa
WP67005140 67005140 Refrigerator Freezer Door Handle
9.2
/10
Our score
Well rated
Scored 9.2/10 or higher
Affiliate link. Price and stock live at Amazon and change there, not on this page.
Best for
Buyers who want screws included
Pros
- Screw included
- ABS plastic build
- Cross-references six part numbers
Cons
- Third-party, not made by Maytag
- Handle type field says knob
Best for
Matching by the longest compatibility list
Pros
- Long Maytag model list
- Replaces WP67005140 and 67005140
- White finish, dimensions listed
Cons
- Third-party, not made by Maytag
- Screws not listed in box
The WP67005140 67005140 Refrigerator Freezer Door Handle from HSJAWA is the most thoroughly documented option in this group. The listing gives cross-reference numbers 1071249, AP6010436, PS11743615 and EAP11743615 alongside the main part numbers, and it publishes long compatibility lists for Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana and Maytag. Maytag models named include PBF1951KEW, MBB1952GRW, MBB1954HEW, GB1924PEKW, GB5525PEAW10, GB6526FEAW10, PBF2253HEW and PBB1951HEW, among others.
That depth matters, because the most reliable way to buy a Maytag refrigerator handle replacement is to find your fridge model number on the label inside the fresh food section and match it to a list. This listing makes that easiest. It also gives measurable specs: white plastic, rectangular pull handle, 8.38 by 3.4 inches and 4.16 ounces.
Installation, per the listing, is a screwdriver job: remove the screws, pull off the old handle, fit the new one and tighten. The listing does not say screws are included, so plan to reuse your original screws. The “universal fit” wording in the listing is marketing; treat it as fitting the models listed, not every fridge from these brands.
- White plastic pull handle
- 8.38 x 3.4 inches
- Long Maytag, Whirlpool, Kenmore and Amana model lists
- Screwdriver installation
No. 02
of 4
Hufewu
67005140 Refrigerator Freezer Door Handle Fit
8.0
/10
Our score
Affiliate link. Price and stock live at Amazon and change there, not on this page.
The 67005140 Refrigerator Freezer Door Handle Fit for Kenmore, Maytag and Whirlpool is sold under the HUFEWU brand, with Jaloparts listed as the manufacturer. Its strongest point is the replaced part list: 67005140, 67001902, 8170990, 1071249, 12610801W and 12285401. If the number stamped on your old handle is one of those older codes, this listing makes the match easy.
The compatibility list is shorter than the first handle’s. For Maytag it names GB1924PEKB12, GB1924PEKW, GB1924PEKW12, GB5525PEAS10, GB5525PEAW10 and GB5525PEAW2, and for Whirlpool it names several CB19G6W and EB2SHKXVD models. The listing states the handle is ABS plastic and that a screw is included, which is useful if your original hardware is stripped or missing.
Two listing details do not line up. The handle type field says “Knob” even though the product is a pull handle, and the dimensions of 9.44 by 3.93 inches differ from the 8.38 by 3.4 inches on the HSJAWA listing for the same part number. Sellers may measure differently, but if your space is tight, measure your old handle before ordering. The listing does not specify a color.
- ABS plastic construction
- Screw included
- Replaces six part numbers
- Model-specific fit
No. 03
of 4
Tekonpro
WP67005140 Refrigerator Freezer Door Handle
9.0
/10
Our score
Affiliate link. Price and stock live at Amazon and change there, not on this page.
Best for
Cross-checking by old part numbers
Pros
- Lists seven replaced part numbers
- White finish
- Simple screw-on install
Cons
- Third-party, not made by Maytag
- Dimensions field looks wrong
The WP67005140 Refrigerator Freezer Door Handle from TEKONPRO is a straightforward white replacement that leads with part numbers. The listing says it replaces WP67005140, 67005140, 1071249, 12285404, 8170990, 67001902 and 12610801W, the widest part-number cross-reference of the three freezer handles.
Its model list covers Kenmore 5966 series fridges plus Whirlpool CB19G6W and EB2SHKXVD models, and it names KitchenAid in the compatibility text as well. The visible list cuts off at a GB5525 entry, so check the full product page for your exact Maytag model. The listing gives the model number WP67005140 and lists the handle itself as the included component, with no mention of screws.
The dimension field lists 1.3 by 1.3 inches, which cannot describe a full freezer handle, so disregard it. The install steps match the others, with one sensible extra tip: wear work gloves while swapping the handle. This one suits you if your old part number is 12285404, which only this listing names. If you are refreshing more than one handle around the house, our door handle with lock guide covers the non-appliance side.
- Replaces seven part numbers
- White finish
- Screw attachment
- Brand and model specific fit
No. 04
of 4
Hsjawa
WPW10187840 Microwave Door Handle Fits
9.8
/10
Our score
Well rated
Scored 9.2/10 or higher
Affiliate link. Price and stock live at Amazon and change there, not on this page.
Best for
Maytag microwave handle repairs only
Pros
- Replaces W10187840 microwave part
- Gray OEM-matched finish
- Maytag MMV model list
Cons
- Microwave handle, not freezer
- Stray unrelated part number in listing
The WPW10187840 Microwave Door Handle Fits Whirlpool and Maytag microwaves, and it is not a freezer handle. It appears in Maytag handle searches because it is a Maytag-compatible door handle, but it will not fit your refrigerator. It is sold by HSJAWA, the same seller as the first handle in this list.
The listing says it directly replaces W10187840, 1456048, AH2330289, EA2330289, AP6016574, PS2330289 and EAP2330289. Maytag compatibility focuses on over-the-range microwave models in the MMV5207 and MMV5165 families. It is a gray, curved plastic pull handle with an OEM-matched finish, attached with screws. The listing advises unplugging the microwave before swapping the handle.
One listing line mentions a WB15X10276 handle, a part number that does not match the rest of the listing, so rely on the WPW10187840 and W10187840 numbers when checking fit. Buy it only if your Maytag microwave handle is the part that failed.
- Replaces W10187840 microwave handle
- Gray, curved, OEM-matched finish
- Maytag MMV5207 and MMV5165 models
- Screw attachment
What Sets These Models Apart
| Product | Appliance | Seller Brand | Color | Screws Listed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WP67005140 67005140 Handle | Refrigerator freezer | HSJAWA | White | Not specified |
| 67005140 Handle Fit | Refrigerator freezer | HUFEWU | Not specified | Yes |
| WP67005140 Handle | Refrigerator freezer | TEKONPRO | White | Not specified |
| WPW10187840 Handle | Microwave | HSJAWA | Gray | Not specified |
Figures in this table are copied from the Amazon listings for these models.
NOTES
Buying Tips for Maytag Freezer Door Handles
Start with your refrigerator’s model number, not its appearance. Maytag, Whirlpool, Kenmore and Amana share a lot of parts, and two fridges that look alike can take different handles. The model tag is usually inside the fresh food compartment on a side wall or near the top. Match it against the compatibility list on the listing you choose, and if possible, check the part number printed on your broken handle as well.
Next, check the hardware. Plastic handles often fail at the screw posts, and the screws themselves can strip. Only one of the freezer handles here lists a screw in the box, so if your original screws are damaged, factor that in. A plastic handle on a busy freezer takes a lot of pulls, so tighten it firmly but do not overtighten into plastic.
Finally, remember that a whirlpool freezer handle listing and a Maytag one can be the same part. That is normal for shared platforms. If you are also shopping for a small second fridge for a game room, our mini fridge with freezer roundup is a good starting point.
FAQ
Is the 67005140 handle made by Maytag?
Not in this comparison. All four products are third-party replacements designed to fit Maytag and related brands.
What is the difference between 67005140 and WP67005140?
The listings treat them as the same part and name both numbers together, so a handle sold as WP67005140 is presented as a replacement for 67005140.
How do I know which Maytag handle to buy?
Find the model number on your refrigerator’s tag and match it to the compatibility list on the product page. The HSJAWA freezer handle has the longest Maytag list of the three.
Can I install a freezer handle myself?
Yes. Each listing describes removing the old handle with a screwdriver and screwing on the new one. No other tools are mentioned.
Will the microwave handle fit my freezer?
No. The WPW10187840 handle is for Whirlpool and Maytag microwaves and is not listed for any refrigerator.
Are screws included with these handles?
Only the HUFEWU 67005140 handle lists a screw as included. The other listings do not specify, so plan to reuse your original screws.
